Revered revisionist western resurfaces

Released nearly in tandem with Sam Peckinpah's "The Wild Bunch" in 1969, George Roy Hill's "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" replaces that film's brutal violence and questionable characters with light humor and a far more likeable band of wrongdoers led by the already iconic Paul Newman and a fresh-faced Robert Redford in one of his first high-profile starring roles.\nCommencing with one of the most effective character introductions in modern movie history, it's not long before Paul Newman is free-spiritedly cavorting on a bicycle to B.J. Thomas' "Raindrops Keep Falling on My Head." Therein lies both the fundamental problem and key strength of the film; essentially a revisionist western and buddy picture that turns the tables on previous genre conceptions while poking fun (sometimes too much fun and with too many one-liners for its own good) at both the genres and itself.\nWith luminescent cinematography from Conrad L. Hall and a punchy, spry script by William Goldman, "Butch" is a joy to watch, even if its humor becomes a bit cloying after an hour or so. Newman and Redford bubble over with the star quality that knighted the film box office platinum, and the plot never becomes overwrought or bogged down in unnecessary details. A classic example of American revisionism of the western mystique, "Butch" belongs on the shortlist of late 1960's classics, but the company it resides near on the American Film Institute's Top 100 Films list ("Clockwork Orange," "Taxi Driver," "Jaws," "Amadeus," "Vertigo") greatly overshadows it.\nDisc 1 boasts insightful commentary from director Hill and screenwriter Goldman, as well as invaluable input from the late cinematographer Hall, and Disc 2 of this set doesn't skimp on the features. The excellent 2005 making-of documentary "All Of What Follows is True" is accompanied by a similar but lesser 1994 doc, while cast interviews from 1994 shed more light on the film, but one can't help but wish Redford and Newman had agreed to share more of their thoughts on the film in 2006. Two more worthy docs, "The Wild Bunch: The True Tale of Butch & Sundance" and "History Through the Lens: Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid: Outlaws Out of Time" reveal just how much of the film is based on fact while offering up interesting tidbits on the real-life outlaws on which the film was patterned.\nHill, Newman, and Redford would collaborate again four years later on "The Sting," where they actually seemed like they were having more fun that they did here. Listed at #50 on the AFI's list of the greatest films ever made, "Butch" is unquestionably overrated, especially in retrospect, but that doesn't change the fact that it's still an incredibly well-made and enjoyable sliver of Americana.