Perhaps the biggest flaw of The Horrible Crowes’ “Elsie,” the
side-project debut of Gaslight Anthem frontman Brian Fallon, is that it
is not exactly what he wanted it to be — the Tom Waits to Gaslight’s
Bruce Springsteen.
Indeed, several of the songs sound only a small step removed from the
Gaslight Anthem’s breakout sophomore effort, “The ’59 Sound.”
At the same time, though, that same batch of songs also comprises many of the record’s highlights.
“Go Tell Everybody” is a prime example of this
one-step-away-from-Gaslight sound. Crisp drumming and Fallon’s familiar
smoky howl, which is in top form in nearly every track, punctuate a tale
of anger after betrayal. This would all sound like vintage Gaslight if
it were not joined by organ that overtakes the guitar and leads the
sonic charge surprisingly well.
Two tracks later, the album hits its high point with the one-two-three
punch of “Ladykiller” (the album’s non-Gaslight sound at its most
effective), “Crush” (a ’59 Sound clone that builds to a powerful climax)
and soulful rocker “Mary Ann.”
Unfortunately, the dull “Cherry Blossoms” precedes the trio and breaks
up what would otherwise be a stellar eight-song streak on a record just
similar and different enough from Gaslight to perfectly tide over fans
until the band’s next album.
Crowes not so horrible
Get stories like this in your inbox
Subscribe