Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Saturday, May 4
The Indiana Daily Student

arts

Men inching women out of country music awards

NASHVILLE, Tenn. -- The nominees for next week's country music awards are a bit more old school than some predecessors and a lot more brawny.\nFor the first time in some 20 years, male singers took all five slots in both the entertainer of the year and newcomer categories.\nSome say the nominations reflect a shift from pop-leaning, crossover acts such as Faith Hill and Shania Twain to the more male-dominated, traditional sounds of Joe Nichols and Buddy Jewell.\n"I think the pop crossover songs are going to be out there. It's still an important part of the overall picture of the country music format, but the difference now is those songs will have to be phenomenal to cut through," said Joel Burke, program director for Denver country station KYGO-FM.\nThe Country Music Association's 37th annual awards show airs live from the Grand Ole Opry House at 8 p.m. EST Wednesday on CBS.\nThis year's nominees chosen by 5,000 industry insiders who belong to the CMA include a few classic country artists and several others who continue that tradition. Dolly Parton, Willie Nelson, Patty Loveless, Randy Travis, George Strait, Alan Jackson, Brad Paisley and Johnny Cash are up for awards, as well as newcomers Jewell, Nichols and Gary Allan.\nToby Keith, who's had a string of testosterone-charged hits with "Who's Your Daddy," "Courtesy of the Red, White & Blue" and "Beer For My Horses," leads all artists this year with seven nominations.\n"We see that pendulum we're always talking about swinging again," said Ed Benson, the CMA's executive director. "In the last year or so, there's been a return to traditional country in sound and production. And I think the voters are trying to recognize a more real, traditional side."\nMen are leading the way. During the first six months of this year, female artists accounted for only four of the 34 top 10 hits on Billboard magazine's country singles chart, according to Billboard. Only the Dixie Chicks managed a No. 1 hit.\nThe story was similar last year, with females scoring five top 10s and two No. 1s in the same period.\nBut in the first six months of 2000, women were strong on the charts 10 top 10 singles by female artists, three of which hit No. 1. Back in 1998, women scored 14 top 10s in that period, half of them No. 1s.\nBenson thinks the trend toward men began with a spate of patriotic anthems after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. Country artists --mostly men -- were among the first to capture the mood in song.\nBenson also believes males have became a larger share of the country music listening and buying audience.\nWhatever the reasons, "the state of the female country singer is a little scary right now," said Dawn Michaels, assistant program director at country station WYGW-FM in Cincinnati.\nIn this year's CMA female vocalist category, Loveless and Parton are nominated with Terri Clark, Martina McBride and Alison Krauss. But Hill and Twain -- each with successful albums and tours -- received not a single nomination.\n"I don't think country audiences were responding to it," Michaels said. "The Faith project especially. There were a lot of big ballads. Nothing like 'This Kiss' songs that are fun."\nMeanwhile, Loveless and Parton have received critics' praise in recent years for music that veers toward bluegrass, but neither has been a commercial force in a long time. Loveless' latest album, "On Your Way Home," came out in September and is her first mainstream country record in two years.\n"I never expected to be nominated in that category, especially not this year," Loveless said. "The CMAs are about country music, and for two years there I was in the bluegrass and acoustic music world."\nBut McBride, the most pop-oriented artist in the female vocalist category, said the strength of industry-voted awards like the CMAs is that they recognize diversity within the genre and are not based on sales. Like motion pictures' Oscars, country music's CMAs don't always go to the big-budget blockbusters.\n"It shouldn't be a popularity contest," McBride said. "I think it's great that these classic artists are still being recognized for their art"

Get stories like this in your inbox
Subscribe