After Sept. 11, many important issues were brushed aside by more pressing matters. The implications of one such issue, human cloning, are so profound that it cannot be ignored much longer.
Researchers at Advanced Cell Technology in Massachusetts Nov. 25, 2001, were the first to clone a human embryo, sparking debate about the legal and moral dimensions of cloning. Clearly, human cloning is an extraordinarily complicated matter. By virtue of that fact alone, it deserves careful deliberation and public dialogue so any permanent legislation truly reflects the considered will of the people.
The dialogue has just begun. In California, a panel of experts commissioned by the state recommended that California ban cloning that would result in the birth of a child (reproductive cloning). The panel also unanimously recommended that California regulate, but not ban, therapeutic cloning. A National Academy of Sciences panel reached a similar conclusion last Friday.