Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Saturday, Dec. 2
The Indiana Daily Student

Indiana’s NFL Trailblazers: 53-Man Roster Performances to Remember

Photo by Dave Adamson on Unsplash

The Colts have achieved the rare feat of winning a Super Bowl while representing two different cities: Baltimore in 1971 and Indianapolis in 2007.

The Indianapolis Colts claimed victory in the NFL Western Conference championships in 1964 and 1968 under the esteemed leadership of head coach Don Shula. Shula subsequently departed for the Miami Dolphins in 1970, yet the Colts triumphed by securing the first AFC Eastern division title and conquering Super Bowl V in that same year.

Fast forward to 2006, and quarterback Manning guided the Colts to their first championship in 36 seasons, emerging triumphant in Super Bowl XLI with a 29-17 win against the Chicago Bears.

Colts vs. Giants
Year: 1958 NFL Championship Game
The Result: Colts won 23-17 

2023 marked the 64th anniversary of the memorable NFL Championship game between the Baltimore Colts and the New York Giants, fittingly dubbed "The Greatest Game Ever Played."

In this epic contest, the Colts emerged victorious with a score of 23-17. This game was truly a spectacle, showcasing the immense talent of both teams. In fact, a staggering total of 17 individuals who would later be inducted into the Professional Football Hall of Fame were involved, including coaches, players, and executives.

The Colts secured their place in history when fullback Alan Ameche made a game-winning touchdown, crossing the goal line with just ten seconds left in overtime. This decisive touchdown culminated in an exhilarating 13-play, 80-yard drive masterminded by the legendary quarterback Unitas, who would later earn a spot in the Hall of Fame.

Ray Berry, renowned for his outstanding catching abilities, delivered a stellar performance in the Championship game, amassing an impressive 178 yards on 12 receptions. In the game's aftermath, Berry described the victory as the pinnacle of his career.

Colts vs. Browns
Year: 2023 NFL Regular Season Game
The Result: Colts lost 39-38 

Not every incredible on-field performance by the Indianapolis Colts has resulted in success, evidenced by the 2023/24 regular game spectacle we witnessed on Sunday, October 22nd, 2023.

The Colts were on track for a win against the Cleveland Browns in their quest to reach the Super Bowl 2024. However, due to contentious calls, victory was prevented in what has been one of the most exciting games of the season so far.

From the beginning of the game, both teams displayed moments of brilliance, making it an equally captivating contest. Jerome Ford's early touchdown for the Browns, featuring a 69-yard run, was the longest play the Colts had allowed all season. In response, Minshew threw a 59-yard touchdown pass to Josh Downs, and Julian Blackmon's interception set up Gardner Minshew's touchdown run.

The final quarter was an emotional rollercoaster, highlighted by Minshew and Pittman's dramatic touchdown connection. Kenny Moore's outstanding performance was also noteworthy, but the turning point came with Darrell Baker Jr.'s consecutive penalties. These penalties placed the Browns on the one-yard line, ultimately leading to their last-minute victory.

In a game filled with controversies, shifts in momentum, and standout performances, the Colts found themselves on the losing side as the Cleveland Browns emerged as winners with a controversial 39-38 scoreline. Also now sports fans now have a new reason to elevate their game with ESPN BET available in the online sports betting world. By using the ESPN Bet promo code, enthusiasts can enhance their betting experience and take their passion for sports to the next level.

Colts vs. Patriots
Year: 2007 NFL Playoff Game
The Result: Colts won 38-34 

This game is truly remarkable and will be remembered as one of the most memorable NFL games, especially for Colts fans. Undoubtedly, it is one of the best, if not the best, games in the history of the Indianapolis Colts.

From Manning's impressive 32-point performance in the second half to Brady's interception by Marlin Jackson, this game will forever hold a special place in the hearts of Colts supporters. The victory secured their spot in the Super Bowl, creating an unforgettable moment for all.

Colts vs. Chiefs
Year: 2014 AFC Wild Card Game
The Result: Colts won 45-44 

Chuck Pagano was astounded by what he saw. Andrew Luck was astounded by what he heard. Colts fans were astounded by the scoreboard, and the Kansas City Chiefs were astounded by their incredibly unfortunate luck.

It seemed incomprehensible.

Just as Luck seemed to be struggling and occasionally played as poorly as he ever has, putting the Colts in a 28-point deficit, the QB somehow flipped momentum. Luck threw 3 of his 4 TDs in the second half, scored on a fumble return, and connected with a wide-open T.Y. Hilton on a 64-yard TD pass, leading the Colts to a seemingly impossible 45-44 wild-card victory.

Indianapolis achieved a remarkable feat by emerging victorious in the game despite being behind by 28 points. They became only the second team in playoff history to stage such an impressive comeback.

Colts vs. Bears
Year: 2007 NFL Super Bowl XLI
The Result: Colts won 29-17 

The Indianapolis Colts' Super Bowl season in 2006-07 is undoubtedly the most remarkable one in their history. After enduring years of struggling teams before the Peyton Manning era, followed by seasons of near misses with Manning, the Colts finally reached the Super Bowl to face the Chicago Bears on a rainy night in Miami.

The game did not start well for the Colts, as the Bears' Devin Hester returned the opening kickoff for a touchdown, giving them a 7-0 lead.

Following an unforgettable halftime show performed by Prince, both teams exchanged field goals in the second half, resulting in a 22-17 Colts lead in the 4Q. It was then Kelvin Hayden at defensive back that sealed the victory by intercepting a pass from the Bears and returning it 56 yards for a TD, thus giving the Colts a commanding 29-17 gap. With the Bears needing at least two touchdowns to win and limited time left, they could not mount a comeback. Finally, the Colts claimed their long-awaited Super Bowl victory.

Despite his relatively average performance (by his standards), Manning was named the Most Valuable Player of the game. He completed 25 of 38 passes for 247 yards, throwing one touchdown and one interception. However, the running backs Joseph Addai (with 144 total yards) and Dominic Rhodes (with 113 rushing yards and one touchdown), as well as the Colts' defense that held the Chicago Bears to 265 yards, who played pivotal roles in securing the victory.

Like what you're reading? Support independent, award-winning college journalism on this site. Donate here.