Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
Wednesday, Dec. 31
The Indiana Daily Student

Dirty albums to become precious treasures

For those unfamiliar with The Replacements or Paul Westerberg (The Replacements' principle songwriter), you should know that The Replacements were one of those college-rock bands of the early '80s who are responsible for the flannel-clad warriors of the early '90s like Pearl Jam and the Screaming Trees. \nAnytime I have ever slapped down the cash for a Replacements or Westerberg album the same thing happens. I go home immediately, listen to it twice and put it on my shelf for six months.\n There must be some kind of aging process for Westerberg's songwriting because after virtually forgetting I own it, I dust it off and put it back in the CD player and discover that since about 1981, the year I was born and the year the Replacements released their debut album Sorry Ma, Forgot to Take Out the Trash, Paul Westerberg has been writing a soundtrack for my life. I would've never concluded upon a first couple listens that I could have any kind of a personal connection to any Westerberg album, until now.\nBefore I signed up for this review, I had never even heard of Grandpaboy, the semi-anonymous side project of Westerberg. So pardon me for being a bit of a novice.\nThe first track "MPLS" is a rockabilly tribute to Westerberg's hometown of Minneapolis, and my first thought was, "Did I pick up the wrong album?" The majority of Dead Man Shake continues in this cross between boogie-woogie-soaked rhythm of the late '60s and early '70s Keith Richards-style feel of country and blues (not exactly what I expected). There are some great covers on this record, like Hank Williams' "I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry." Although this isn't my favorite kind of rock, after each listen I like it more and more.\nCome Feel Me Tremble begins with a wonderfully dirty alt-country track "Dirty Diesel," and I soon realize this album will be phenomenal from first listen. And then the second track, "Making Me Go" begins, and I hear all the power-pop brilliance that I thought only Big Star's Alex Chilton could produce. \nOn "My Daydream" he does a stupendous job lifting the "come on" rave-up from The Beatles' "Please Please Me." This is a dirty little power-pop album that leaves in all the little mistakes and has the vocals really low in the mix. I love this from track one to track 14.

Get stories like this in your inbox
Subscribe