Commentary

‘Grey’s Anatomy’ meets universal health care

POSTED AT 08:25 PM ON Nov. 12, 2009 | PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (6)

Universal health care is a pretty big deal.

But for many of IU’s less concerned members of society, “Grey’s Anatomy” is a bigger deal. It’s an accurate representation of the typical American hospital setting, you know.

I wonder if the “Grey’s” fanatics among us realize how their beloved show could change if the House’s recently passed health care bill is approved by the Senate.

Let’s start with a little exercise: Picture your favorite “Grey’s” doctor. Is it overdramatic Meredith? Overzealous Christina? What about the super-annoying Lexi-pedia?

You may have noticed how I didn’t include Izzie’s name above. That’s because she’s dead. She died a long time ago. Before her little run-in with Georgey in the elevator.

Why? Simple. She was just another number. Her advanced form of cancer wasn’t treated with the advanced medicine it could have been, had she the right to choose her insurer.

Under the government-run system, the overall costs are more important than the individual needs of the patient.

Everyone with cancer gets the same care, but that type of care is greatly depleted until the government can afford to offer it to everyone.

And under the new system, she had to wait to get any treatment at all. All the new hoops she had to jump through cost her life.

I didn’t include McSteamy or McDreamy as options, either. They don’t work at Seattle Grace anymore. The plastic surgery and neuro units were cut.

Why? They were too specialized and too expensive. The hospital doesn’t have the budget for these important medical practices anymore. Under the employer-based payment system they had before, the hospital had the funding necessary to offer these services. But not now.

With Derek no longer a doctor, it’s safe to bet Meredith killed herself. Or, to create a spinoff show, she ran off with someone she met at a bar.

But no one watches the show for Meredith. It’s the hardcore Dr. Bailey that keeps us tuning in.

Well, she’s gone, too. The hospital didn’t have the funds to improve its technology. Seattle Grace, like other hospitals across the U.S., no longer has an edge in medical technology on international competition. And since Bailey’s all about being the best, she shipped off to Asia.

I know what you’re thinking. With Bailey gone, the internship program will suffer.
Wrong. There are no interns. There’s no incentive for young people to enter the medical field anymore. The government-run system drastically reduces the salary of doctors, which is needed to offset the high expenses of medical school and running one’s own practice.

America’s medical field is no longer about constant improvement and doing the best for the patient; it’s simply about providing a low, but identical, level of care for everyone. America’s brightest college students want a challenge, so they’ve chosen a new field of study.

Sorry to burst your “Grey’s” bubble, but this is reality, after all. And with universal health care, the reality is that America’s hospitals are no longer what they used to be.

“ER” should be out on DVD soon.

PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (6)



POST A COMMENT:



Name:
*
Email:
*
E-mail address will not be published.
Comments:

Verify image:
Security Text
  *
 
 
All Comments  (6)

6. Posted by Dumb at 5:19 PM on Nov 15, 2009 | Report this comment

Since when are journalists more aware of the current health care bill's provisions than actual public health employees? Please, shut your yap. Journalists are good at one thing: acting like they know something while mudslinging left and right mumbo-jumbo. The only skill journalists have is convincing ignorant people that watch too much tv to think the way they do. So before you attempt to compare the health care bill to a soap opera, read between the lines. And better yet, dump your parents' health care coverage and purchase your own...and we shall see if you enjoy spending tons of money each month.

5. Posted by oldliberalalum at 7:7 PM on Nov 14, 2009 | Report this comment

I don't understand what everyone's problem is with this article. I mean, take one token young republican female, who has had everything in her life handed to her, who is currently probably on her upper middle class familys' health insurance, even as a 19-22 year old "adult", and then generic love for a generic TV show, and apply right wing stereotypes of the fear of universal health care, and Voila! One more shitty article by her. If you've read her before, this isn't anything new. And that she watches Greys anatomy? What a shock. You can tell she buys into the talking points of every hack when one of the attacks involve a fake patient "having to wait". The horrors. not being able to request on demand medicine that you can't afford.

4. Posted by Steve Stanzak at 4:54 PM on Nov 13, 2009 | Report this comment

This is a timely article, considering what's been happening in the show as well as the current debate on health care occurring now in Congress. Unfortunately, the author makes up fake scenarios about the show rather than examining the actual evidence from the show. If she had actually watched the show, she would have noticed that her arguments are completely contradicted in the show itself. First, under the current PRIVATELY-RUN health care system, Seattle Grace has recently had severe financial troubles that has led to its merger with another hospital in order to cut costs. Unfortunately, this also means that numerous doctors and nurses had to be cut and the quality of care in general has also decreased. Cuts have been made in staff, equipment, research, and the number of pro bono cases. Izzie is alive, but she (or more accurately, her husband) is stuck with a huge $200,000 medical bill, and this is WITH insurance, from the hospital where she works! Right now, the doctors are discouraged from taking risks that would cost the hospital more money, leading to a decline in innovation, research, and patient options. For example, only a couple weeks ago, Isaac, another hospital employee was denied a high-risk and expensive procedure because the chief didn't want to spend money on something that might not pay off. Only through Derek's direct disobedience was Isaac's life saved. Just last night the Chief tried to deny treatment to a friend of Izzie's who couldn't afford the procedure; only when she threatened to go to the press did he relent. It's fine if Ms. Lafree wants to argue against a public healthcare option, but her poor choice of evidence and her selective use of facts weakens her argument and makes her look, perhaps rightly, foolish.

3. Posted by RC at 2:58 PM on Nov 13, 2009 | Report this comment

Great Article.

2. Posted by PeterK at 12:54 PM on Nov 13, 2009 | Report this comment

All I needed to know was summed up by this statement: "There’s no incentive for young people to enter the medical field anymore. The government-run system drastically reduces the salary of doctors," You think that how much money you make, how rich you can become, is the only reason people go into medicine? Is profit all you think matters? Did it ever occur to you people might go into medicine to help people, and could be content with a modest income and standard of living, while doing good work? Obviously not, otherwise you would have had the sense not to include this absurd statement. Maybe money is all that matters to you and I pity you, for it is likely you will never have enough to satisfy yourself and will live in perpetual envy of those who you think have more. I fear you will simply grow ever more bitter while living a shallow life. Very sad indeed.

1. Posted by Justin at 9:16 AM on Nov 13, 2009 | Report this comment

I wonder if the person who wrote this article has ever had to deny coverage to someone because their insurance either doesn't cover their procedure, or that it their co-pay is too high. I am an IU alumni and a hospital administrator, so when I see un-educated individuals writing propaganda such as this, it makes me furious. Next time why not try interviewing someone in health care and then write a proper "oppinion" article with some truth to it.


Email

Your Name: *
Your Email: *  
To Email: *  
Subject: IDSnews.com | ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ meets universal health care
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text



*