Campus

Life-changing journey takes IU senior to Tibet, Thailand, back home

POSTED AT 12:32 AM ON Nov. 6, 2009 | PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (16)

Final exams, friend problems and stress about plans for the next school year upset Abby Borger as she walked, crying, down the overcast, polluted streets of Nanjing, China last year.

On her way to unwind at an art museum, the overcast sky suddenly cleared and a flaky snow began to fall. Borger looked up and saw a Chinese monk walking toward her.

Neither the monk nor Borger said a word, but when they passed, he handed her a gold-plated card.

A little smaller than a playing card, it had a picture of Guanyin Pusa, the Buddha of compassion, on one side and a blessing written in Chinese on the other.

“After that moment, I decided to convert to Buddhism,” Borger said. “Like, right there in the middle of the street.”

The card now lies in a music shop in Tibet with the other belongings Borger left behind when she was asked to leave the country.

Borger, a senior in the Individualized Major Program with a minor in Tibetan studies, asked that her name be changed for her own safety. She planned to study overseas at Tibet University in Lhasa this fall semester.

Borger said she arrived in Lhasa about a year after she arrived in China and moved into the dorms at Tibet University on Aug. 28.

Classes began on Sept. 16, a Wednesday. The next day, she went to renew her expired visa and was told that all foreign visitors were going to be asked to leave before Oct. 1, as the government expected outbreaks of violence during the 60th anniversary of Chairman Mao Zedong’s and the People’s Republic of China’s rise to power.

“Oct. 1 is sort of like America’s Fourth of July,” said Gedun Rabsal, a Tibetan language lecturer at IU. “They want to celebrate peacefully and without interruptions. And if there are interruptions, they don’t want foreigners to see.”

On Oct. 18, Borger finally arrived back in Bloomington, missing some personal items but, instead, possessing a story she feels others need to hear.

“Basically, I’ve seen more than the Chinese government knows that I’ve seen,” she said.

Borger witnessed beatings of monks and other natives on an almost daily basis in Lhasa.

“It’s a good thing I got out of there alive and in one piece,” she said. “I didn’t want to see my friends dying.”

***

Five days after Borger heard of the ruling from the visa office, Tibet University informed her that classes would be canceled beginning the next day and students would need to find their own ways out of the country, she said.

She obtained a temporary visa and caught a train to Lanzhou, China on Sept. 28, three days before the celebration was to occur.

“In the three months before I got back to the states, I spent about a fifth of my time on trains, planes, buses and backs of trucks with loads of barley and sheep,” she said. “The only thing crazy enough to follow me around is my violin.”

After traveling by two trains and a plane, Borger found herself in Thailand for two weeks, waiting to hear if the situation cleared up in Lhasa.

She tried to contact her friends from Lhasa while in Thailand. Their phones would ring the first time she called, she said, but no one would answer. On subsequent attempts, it would say the line was disconnected.

Borger said she is now on the Chinese government’s watch list. While in Thailand, she said she tried to send an e-mail about her experience to her family and friends. The e-mail bounced back three times, she said, and she could not access her school account for three weeks.

After a friend in China eventually received her message, Borger said her friend’s phone was shut down for the rest of the day.

“If people in Tibet are known to have contact with me, they might disappear,” she said.

Two days after Oct. 1, Borger said the Chinese government reported at least 200 people had died in Urumqi, a city north of Tibet.

“Basically what I know is this,” she said. “These four Tibetans were convicted this past week and publicly executed. Come Oct. 1, many people died when they came out to protest. It happens every year around this time.”

The Chinese government cracked down on security in Tibet after demonstrations that took place on March 10 of last year, said Elliot Sperling, associate professor of Tibetan studies.

The date marked the 49th anniversary of a mass protest in 1959, which eventually culminated in the capitol of Lhasa, where hundreds of thousands of people surrounded the Dalai Lama’s palace to protect him from danger.

The demonstrations spread across the plateau and ultimately exploded into violence.
The protests received worldwide coverage when journalists located in China to cover the Olympics spoke about the violence taking place, Sperling said.

“March 10 has always been sensitive,” he said. “Tibet is under tremendously tight security this year. And if there is violence, they don’t want foreigners to see it.”

In February of this year, Borger said she spent the Chinese New Year with the family of a doctor in Xiahe, China.

The people of Tibet did not formally celebrate the holiday, she said, in order to honor those who were murdered during the 2008 demonstrations and those who died in an earthquake that occurred a few months previous to the celebration.

Foreigners were not allowed in the city at the time, Borger said, and she was not permitted to leave the doctor’s house. Three days after New Year’s, Borger said she left the family so as not to bring them harm.

She wore Tibetan clothing and a scarf shielded her entire face except her eyes, which she hid beneath brown contact lenses. Borger said she disguised herself in order to make it out of the city to a bus station unharmed.

Borger arrived at the bus safely, but as it pulled out of the station, she said she saw three Tibetan men being tossed into the street from a police station.

Afraid she was going to throw up the tea the family had given her, she watched as five policemen beat the men with sticks and broken bottles. By the time the bus left the station, blood covered the ground and the three men were not moving.

“Do I want to be here for a full year?” Borger remembers asking herself. “I don’t know if I can handle this.”

Looking back, Borger’s time in Tibet and China had many ups and downs. She found religion, she said, but she also saw acts of violence that will stay with her for the rest of her life.

“For someone in my position, a 20-year-old white girl from Chicago, that’s tough for me to deal with. ... Tibet has cured me, and it has broken me.”

PRINT | Email | SHARE | COMMENTS (16)





Name: *
Email: *
E-mail address will not be published.
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text
  *
 
 
All Comments  (16)

Posted by jade at 1:38 PM on Nov 09, 2009 | Report this comment

How sorry I am for a person who said she has converted into buddhison and telling such a lie. Tibet is a pure place and not welcome the rubbish from any part of the world; Tibet is not the place who want make some pocket money by creating rubbish; this kind of person will be expelled by any school in the world.But she is only 20, may be buddha will forgive her for her youth.

Posted by Josh B. at 8:33 AM on Nov 09, 2009 | Report this comment

I know this girl, and she needs help. Melissa, if you read this, get help from CAPS. Give them a call at 812-855-5711. A couple of other posters suggested this, and they are right. You aren't dealing with this well.

Posted by CP at 1:43 AM on Nov 09, 2009 | Report this comment

This is the most crazy crap I have ever heard! I am a foreigner who lives in Lhasa and lives on the Tibet University campus!!!! There are currently 15+ foreign students and 6 foreign teachers at the University that DID NOT have to find their own way to 'escape'. I personally met this girl on the Tibet University campus and I was quite shocked at the clothes she was wearing!!!! She looked like she had just stepped out of a crazy Tibetan fashion show! It's quite appalling to know that people actually print stuff like this when they don't see, for sure, if things are true! This is a perfect example of American propaganda!!! Yes, as American's we have freedom of speech but get real! I can't read any of this and believe any of it....and I live in Lhasa! Yes, there are problems in Tibet......but stuff like this just makes it worse because it's FALSE!!!!!!! From what I heard on campus, she was told to leave because she kept coming in late at night drunk and bloody!! I guess after this comment I'll be blacklisted from Western Buddhists, huh?

Posted by SL at 6:27 PM on Nov 07, 2009 | Report this comment

When a high educational institute, where I thought should be the last clean earth in the whole world, is utilized by and actively involved in the ugliness of politics and raising student haters who don't even know what critical thinking is, what the hell on earth are we still expecting for?

Posted by William at 6:20 PM on Nov 07, 2009 | Report this comment

Thank you IDS for a perfect example of pointless, self-absorbed drivel that should never be allowed to see the light of day. I am amazed at how detached from reality Ms. "Borger" actually is. She was never in any danger while in China, and the idea that she had to wear a disguise to leave just shows how clueless she is. The easiest way to get out of a restricted part of China is to show yourself as an American student - you'll get a first-class ticket back to Beijing in a flash. Instead, it is those poor Hans and Tibetans foolish enough to befriend her who are actually in danger. What kind of selfish person would try contacting Tibetans by phone, knowing full well that doing so would cause them to be questioned by PRC officials? Yet Ms. Borger not only made that mistake once, but then repeats it in an online publication that will likely be noticed by PRC authorities and cause these poor people even more harm. Many Americans study in China every year, including in Tibet and Xinjiang, a region in western China with similar issues. These students manage to study there without being dumb enough to put their friends and colleagues in danger, or to engage in such ridiculous activity as wearing "native disguises" (apparently Ms. Borger isn't aware that the need to dress in disguise to travel around Asia disappeared about the same time as the British Empire). Instead of printing the account of a clueless attention-seeker who makes IU students studying overseas look like fools, the IDS should take time to interview the many students in East Asian and Central Eurasian studies who do meaningful research throughout the tense Chinese border regions, and actually improve our understanding of the complex issues facing minorities in the PRC.

Posted by david plaff at 4:19 PM on Nov 07, 2009 | Report this comment

Very disappointed on IDS to printing such rediculous article on its front page. This is defamation and IDS may be sued for defamation. No single TOP US University student newspaper would do such thing as IDS just did.

Posted by Jackson Boyar at 12:42 PM on Nov 07, 2009 | Report this comment

I am simply disgusted with the IDS for printing this story. Not only did the story tarnish China's already weak image among American college students, but it did so based on one girl's OPINIONS. A bias story like this has no place in a college newspaper, let alone the front page! I'm sure that Ms. Borger did in fact experience Han-minority discrimination while traveling through Western China. I've been to Western China myself, and it is not uncommon to see such things. However, accusing Chinese authorities in Tibet of beating monks on a daily basis is ludicrous. There are numerous Western reporters stationed in Xinjiang and Tibet, so I image we would have seen stories about persistent violence and 200 some people killed in Urumqi had it ACTUALLY happened. After briefly attending her lecture yesterday afternoon, I am now convinced that Ms. Borger, while devoted and passionate to her studies, is incredibly confused and likely using this story for media attention. She spent the majority of her time in the spotlight preaching about her academic accomplishments and alienating her audience. I personally hope there is some sort of backlash from this terrible cover story. I don't often find myself defending the Chinese government, but this story literally made me sick.

Posted by Arthur Borged at 10:4 AM on Nov 07, 2009 | Report this comment

Ms. Borger is quite out of touch. I submitted a longer, detailed response, but the democracy here don't allow no answer longer than 2,000 characters. In short, I've been teaching at universities in China for the past six years -- nicest folks and students I've ever seen in 30+ years of teaching in four or five different countries. Never had more problems with the copshops here than in France, Sweden, Finland and Hong Kong, for example.

Posted by Taiwan at 7:32 PM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

This summer I studied in Taiwan and my friend got deported for speaking his mind. I don't feel as though this girl's story is very credible, though. If she really cared that much she would have stayed.

Posted by EMA at 5:21 PM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

You've got to be kidding me. What romanticized (and at other times unfairly accusatory) drivel this is. Converting to Buddhism "like, right there in the middle of the street" after receiving a gold card from an exotic monk? Jesus. "Ms. Borger" is not the first foreigner to be "kicked out" of China (as if she did something brave or dangerous that necessitated it) or placed on some kind of government list. How in the world does "hearing about 200 deaths in Urumqi" (not "Uramqi," as whoever put together the map of her "journey" on page 8 of the paper wrote) become part of her journey through China? By the way, "Abby Borger" should probably think twice about giving advertised public talks if she *really* wants to protect her identity from the evil government of China.

Posted by Sharon at 1:39 PM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

"It's all about me!" Did anyone else get this vibe from the article?

Posted by Marie at 1:37 PM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

I hope that Ms. Borger gets professional help in dealing with the post-traumatic stress of what she has seen and experienced.

Posted by Kim at 1:5 PM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

Talk about running away from your problems...

Posted by NA at 8:55 AM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

Moving story. I'm from the region and so am aware of the situation there. The western world needs to know how the other half lives and the inhumanities their biggest trading partner country (China) enforces on a daily basis. Guess which country holds the most US Treasury bonds and is still buying to "help" end the recession?

Posted by tib boy at 7:40 AM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

Borger, thank you for sharing your facts. you take care Peace will win at the end.

Posted by Bill at 6:56 AM on Nov 06, 2009 | Report this comment

I will pray for Tibet.


Email

Your Name: *
Your Email: *  
To Email: *  
Subject: IDSnews.com | Life-changing journey takes IU senior to Tibet, Thailand, back home
Comments:
Verify image: Security Text



*